A good ecommerce agency should be able to tell you what it would investigate before it asks you to raise your ad budget. Bring one problem, such as rising acquisition cost or weak conversion on your top product, and see how each team would work through it. Then compare the scope, people, fees, and ownership terms in writing.
Bring a short brief to every call
Give each candidate the same information. Include your store URL, main products, channels, approximate spend, and the problem you want to solve. Share the range you can afford for the engagement, including creative and implementation. Keep private customer and order details for a later, secure review.
Write down what success would change for the business. If you need to acquire more first-time customers without losing money on the first order, say so. That tells the agency to ask about contribution, returns, and shipping. If you need someone to take over weekly execution, ask who would actually run it.
Run the same interview with every agency
| Ask about | What to look for |
|---|---|
| --- | --- |
| Diagnosis | A few checks they can explain, plus the evidence that would change their mind |
| Team | Named roles for strategy, account work, creative, and reporting |
| Scope | Work included, work billed separately, and decisions your team still owns |
| Reporting | A baseline, a review window, and a way to reconcile ad reports with store orders |
| Handoff | Written terms for account access, creative files, reporting, and work in progress |
Ask for a first-month plan you can check
Suppose your store is getting plenty of visits and shoppers regularly abandon after viewing the product page. One proposal might put most of the first month into new ads. Another might start by checking what the ads promise, where they land, and how shipping and variants appear on mobile. Ask each team how it would decide which task comes first. Use the product page audit to give the conversation a concrete starting point.
A workable plan names the person doing each task and the result you should see. For example, the agency could deliver a baseline for one hero product, a set of annotated findings, and one agreed test with a budget and review date. You can then check whether the work happened before you evaluate the outcome.
Read the proposal before you compare fees
Put the management fee, production, software, setup, and ad spend on separate lines. If fees change as spend rises, ask for a written example at your current budget and at the next level you are considering. Also ask how an engagement ends and which accounts, reports, and files your team keeps.
If the proposals still differ mainly in how much execution they include, use the agency versus consultant guide. For a Shopify store, use the Shopify growth agency questions to check who will work in the store and how they test changes.
Talk through your shortlist with Evan Weber
D2C Champion was built by Evan Weber, founder of Experience Advertising. If you want help framing your brief or evaluating where to start, share your store URL, current channels, and the main decision on your plate. Talk with Evan at Experience Advertising.
